Neither of these are very practical, which is why having a quality diaper pail that contains odors well is essential for new parents. In this case, you can use regular garbage bags and dont fret over odor containment, because youre removing the smelly mess every day (or more frequently). If youve narrowed down your choice to Playtex Diaper Genie Complete vs. Munchkin Step Diaper Pail, my comparison should help you make the final decision. The Munchkin Step diaper pail can be used with both the Munchkin diaper rings, and the snap, seal, and toss bags. Munchkin had bags scented with lavender and baking soda. Diaper Genie vs. Guaranteed to fit or your money back (this refill is guaranteed to fit all diaper Genie pails excluding diaper Genie Twistaway system, as well as guaranteed to fit both the Munchkin Step and Pail diaper pails. We spent many hours on research to finding munchkin vs diaper genie, reading product features, product specifications for this guide. Backed with a Masters Degree in Public Health, a Bachelor of Science in Health Promotion, a long career in health and safety, and 10 years of hands on experience using, researching, and testing baby products, Allison loves to use her parenting experience to support and encourage other parents. check out Munchkin deodorizers & refills here, ranking of the best Diaper Genie alternatives, Get your Munchkin Step + FREE travel pail here >>, Stokke Steps vs. Tripp Trapp Review & Comparison of Stokke High Chairs. No pungent smell filling up the air of your baby room here! Munchkin Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail Refill Rings, 2,176 Count, 8 Pack. In this Diaper Genie vs Munchkin Step review, we have compared both diaper pails compare, focusing on usability, odor prevention, price, and more so you can find the perfect diaper pail for you and your little one! Here are some things to consider. The main difference between the two is the Munchkins self-sealing system, which really does a better job at odor control over the Diaper Genies folding slats. The Diaper Genie has lower upfront price than Munchkin plastic pail. Both the Diaper Genie and the Munchkin Step are made of plastic, and can be easily wiped down should the need arise. Make sure this fits by entering your model number. They arent super expensive, but a busy mom with a newborn doesnt need to be thinking about ordering something like carbon filters for a diaper pail. When you lift the lid to put a new diaper in, you may get a little stinky sniff, but its not a big waft and goes away when the lid is down. Also, they recommend changing them out every 90 days, giving you more time than the carbon filters of the Playtex Diaper Genie Complete. The Diaper Gene releases a bad smell into the air when you open it to drop in a new diaper, the Munchkin only allows a tiny bit of stink to escape. (For every diaper pail sold, Munchkin will plant a tree. The diaper bins that hold a weeks worth of diapers stink when u change it, a regular can changed daily is better, I had a diaper genie with my first and it did not hold up well as she got bigger. 11 kids' books about groundbreaking women for Women's How to Choose the Best Diaper Pail for You. Truthfully, no one wants a smelly nursery. Diaper Genie: Main Similarities & Differences Similarities May be used for disposable or cloth diapers Different colors available Differences Ubbi Diaper Pail Pros. Free shipping. And if you like this guide on Diaper Genie vs Munchkin Step, then youll love our other diapering guides on Huggies Snug And Dry vs Little Movers, how long can I leave a wet diaper on, Hello Bello vs Pampers, and best diapers to prevent blowouts. The refills last a bit longer than the Diaper Genie ones, so it is a bit cheaper in the long run, but its much more difficult to find Dekor Plus refills in brick-and-mortar stores and there are not as many third-party options. A carbon filter to absorb odors, and you can easily buy replacements if it becomes ineffective. Dkor - Plus is around $40 and Baby Trend - Diaper Champ Deluxe is around $30. I have the munchkin for my 2 year old (had since birth) I love it. Keep Odors Away: 7-layer smell-bloc technology helps help trap odors . Note : Not for use with Munchkin Step and Pail Diaper Pails. So why isn't it our top pick? Diaper Genie vs. Main wish is odor holding up and easy to get diapers in- even a heavy filled one with less squishing as possible! We'll be in touch soon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. I wasnt a fan of the diaper genie. Please whitelist our site to get all the best deals and offers from our partners. Read reviews before buying anything other than the Munchkin brand bags. Try it now. I have yet to have issues with it months later. The steel diaper pail can hold up to 55 dirty diapers. A Group Leader is a What to Expect community member who has been selected by our staff to help maintain a positive, supportive tone within a group. Please whitelist our site to get all the best deals and offers from our partners. Hey,FTM and wondering if anyone has had any experience of one or both of the diaper genie complete or munchkin step diaper pails?Any recommendations welcome, thanks . If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Spray the interior of the pail with a mixture of borax, vinegar, and tea tree oil and rub it in with a cleaning rag in circular motions to remove mold and mildew. Plus, because of its proprietary refills, its long-term costs were the highest among our finalists. $25. You dont have to try squeeze and extra full diaper into the pail and you can easily keep hold of your little one, without having to bend down. He is a Massachusetts native and has covered electronics, cameras, TVs, smartphones, parenting, and more for Reviewed. Buy at Amazon Then, you can pull down more of the continuous liner and start fresh. Use More Than One Diaper Pail Deodorizer. Credit: Reviewed.com / TJ Donegan. With the long list of baby gadgets, clothes and accessories you need to buy, you might be wondering if you need a diaper pail. ?Thanks in advanced! Seller 100% positive. The Dekor Plus is also expensive to buy replacements for, with refills costing around $7 onlineif you buy them in bunches. Your IP: It is difficult to find off-brand bags that fit the Munchkin Step pail, so beware of liner bags that claim they fit the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail! No need to bend over, as the foot pedal opening does all the work. The foot pedal opening mechanism is easy to use. Whilst the Munchkin Step wins on odor control, the Diaper Genie is more than effective at controlling odors. Others allow you to use standard trash bags. Munchkin Diaper Pail & Refills - $40 (new market) Munchkin Diaper Pail2 Refill RingsLike New$40 OBOPatented self-sealing . After looking into the most popular pails on the market, we think the best diaper pail and diaper genie on the market is the Playtex Diaper Genie Complete (available at Amazon for $49.97) . When it comes to shortlisting your favorite option, its important to know the key differences. New. It is also tall so you don't need to bend down to use it. The puck deodorizer can be refilled with standard baking soda. Lets take a look at how the Diaper Genie and Munchkin Step compare, and the features that set the two apart. Diaper Genie is popular because of its superior odor control while Munchkin is a firm favorite because of its built-in antimicrobial properties. For the ones that use special refill bags and the squeegee push method, you will most likely be greeted with a huge snake of soiled diapers contained within the bags. The Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is definitely taller than the Ubbi Pail by roughly 4 inches. 0 Compare . Beyond that, this is a sturdy standby that performs better than more expensive models and will help keep your nursery from smelling less than fresh. However, the foot pedal is great for hands-free disposal. The Diaper Genie Complete has a capacity of 25-35 diapers, while the Munchkin Step can hold approximately 30 before you need to change the bag. Copyright Proud Happy Mama PTY LTD 2023 | All Rights Reserved | PRIVACY|TERMS|DISCLOSURE | ACCESSIBILITY |CONTACT, Munchkin Arm & Hammer Puck Baking Soda Cartridge, Diaper Genie Bags Refills 270 (Pack of 3), Munchkin Diaper Pail Refill Rings (2 Pack), Baby Items Starting With A to Z Checklist. The recommendations in this guide are based on thorough product and market research by our team of expert product reviewers. The idea is to save on waste and use less plastic. Munchkin UV Snap, Seal & Toss Diaper Pail Refill Bags - 20pk Munchkin 30 $19.79 When purchased online Buy 1 get 1 25% off diapering supplies Diaper Dekor Classic Diaper Pail Refills - 2pk Diaper Dekor 103 $11.99 When purchased online Munchkin Arm & Hammer Diaper Bag Refill Munchkin 244 $6.29 - $9.39 When purchased online Coming in first is a diaper pail you are probably familiar with and have seen at countless baby showers. Unlike the Diaper Genie, which creates a small antechamber for the dirty diaper to sit in, the Munchkin Step twists the top of the bag to create a mini seal when you close the lid. In terms of odor prevention, this system is best, but it has a noticeable downside. The Munchkin Step pail is tall and has an out of reach button for little fingers, but neither of these pails have a child lock. The sealed ring on the Munchkin Step is better at keeping odors locked away, but the Diaper Genie still performs incredibly well. The Munchkin Step is a foot pedal operated diaper pail with a clever twist and seal method used to keep odors in. Group Leaders arent expected to spend any additional time in the community, and are not held to a set schedule. If you feel a message or content violates these standards and would like to request its removal please submit the following information and our moderating team will respond shortly. It is easy to use with is foot pedal for easy, hygienic and hands-free opening. Diaper Genie boasts Double Air-Tite clamps that work together with a carbon filter to deter odor build-up. So fresh and so clean. That falls apart when you have to put any remotely messy diapers into the Step. Reviewed's mission is to help you buy the best stuff and get the most out of what you already own. I'm an experience mom of two, wife, writer, editor, and passionate parenting advocate! $15.19. YES do this. Use of this site is subject to our terms of use and privacy policy. Uses regular trash bags and definitely traps the smell inside. But, I like to try things out & form my own opinion. Amazon Associates Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.Home | About | Contact | Privacy Policy. Baking soda provides safe, effective and natural odor elimination. There are a few other Diaper Genie models out there, but lets keep it simple: my review is specifically for this Playtex Diaper Genie Complete, not the Diaper Genie Expressions or Diaper Genie Essentials. Everything we recommend Our pick Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail The best diaper pail $70 from. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. Comes with extra bags. These diaper pails advertise that you need to use special bags with them, or their own proprietary bags. Its a little more money upfront, but we highly recommend jumping up to the Diaper Genie Complete. The Genie pails advertise that they are anti-microbial the pail itself, as well as the liner bags, this helps minimize the spread of germs. prefer it over the diaper genie. The Munchkin Step is slightly bigger than the Diaper Genie, but both have roughly the same capacity. The Munchkin mechanism also twists the bag to prevent odors from escaping. Get the best deals and the best advice dropped right in your inbox. Though it doesn't trap odor as well as our top pick, the Ubbi Steel is one of the few options for anyone who doesnt want to get stuck buying expensive, proprietary refill bagsor anyone planning to use cloth diapers. The hinge can also often catch the bag if you pull it straight up and out, meaning its very easy to wind up with a ripped bag full of dirty diaperspretty much every parents worst nightmare. Its not noticeable with a newborn or just one to two diapers, but when the bag is nearly full its impossible to escape. Required fields are marked *. Arm & Hammer 158 votes Ubbi Diaper Pail 18% 30 votes Diaper Genie (or elite) 25% 41 votes Arm & Hammer diaper pail 12% 20 votes I visit the garbage daily! Its easy to see that the Genie requires more carbon filter replacements over the course of a year. Functionality Like PP, I'm looking into the Ubbi this time. On the one hand, its it an easy, one-handed operation to drop the dirty diaper into the pail. With this diaper pail, you do need to push the diaper into the pail, it will not just drop in like with the Diaper Genie (you might feel a bit dirty after this, but I certainly hope youre washing your hands after a diaper change, anyway). These are made with 7-layer of film, and have a pleasant lavender scent. Munchkin Step $64.75 960 Reviews Buy on Amazon Size 12.25 x 27.63 x 13 inches Material Plastic Hands-Free Yes Dekor Mini Hands-Free Diaper Pail $24.95 - - Buy on Amazon Size 7 x 7 x 10 inches Material Plastic Hands-Free Yes Safety 1st Easy Saver Munchkin Arm & Hammer Bubula Steel Dekor Classic Hands-Free Akord Slim Adult Diaper Pail $21.12 $49.99 22% 35 votes I use something else. The new Diaper Genie Complete is equipped with the patented Odor Lock Technology, which creates an effective barrier between odors and the outside environment. Nothing keeps smell in. Munchkin Step Diaper Pail A lot of parents already trust the Munchkin brand, so the Munchkin Step Diaper Pail is another clear option as an alternative to the Diaper Genie. we have a munchkin one. An out-of-reach lock prevents little children from causing big disasters. Specs at a glance: Measures 14 x 12 x 24 inches Holds 30 newborn diapers Weighs 12 pounds Made of plastic Uses special Snap, Seal & Toss bags What We Love Patented self-sealing technology Comes with a starter refill ring and one Snap, Seal & Toss bag Lets start by taking a look at both the Diaper Genie and the Munchkin Step, to see what they have to offer. >> Munchkin vs. Many diaper pails have a squeegee-style contraption that pushes diapers deep down to the bottom of the barrel. Additionally, the Genie also has built-in antimicrobials to prevent the spread of bacteria. I am a FTM and currently making my baby registry. I got the arm & hammer munchkin one for this baby and am super excited to try it!! They even look pretty similar! Purchases made through the links below may earn us and our publishing partners a commission. The Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail, however, while a very good choice in its own right, falls just a bit short of being remarkable. If you really start to notice a smell build up, you can clean a plastic diaper pail with baking soda. The Expressions may look great with the designer sleeves, but its small, expensive to own, and requires you to force squishy diapers into it. 2005-2023Everyday Health, Inc., a Ziff Davis company. I even bag mine with those diaper sacks and it still stinks when I open it, but if I dont you can smell it a mile away even when its closed. Both the Diaper Genie and the Munchkin Step use a filter to capture the smells that will inevitably leak through the bag. Each one uses an additional accessory in the lid to help stop the stink. In some, the liners were tough to change; in others, they required you to shove squishy, messy diapers through a trapdoor, or they simply don't absorb odor and stunk up the joint. These are extremely popular diaper pails on the market right now, but there are many differences between them. We empty it out 1-2 times a week. This item: Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer, #1 in Odor Control, Award-Winning, Includes 1 Refill Ring and 1 Snap, Seal & toss Bag $63.95 Munchkin Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail Snap, Seal, 20 Count $20.62 ($1.03/Count) Munchkin Arm & Hammer Diaper Pail Refill Rings, 544 Count, 2 Pack, 272 Count $14.59 ($7.30/Count) Learn more about, Twins & Multiples: Your Tentative Time Table, PLEASE give me your honest review Munchkin VS Diaper Genie. However, it is more expensive, both up front and in the long-run, because you will probably have to buy the name-brand refill rings. How dirty diapers go in: Many diaper pails have a squeegee-style contraption that pushes diapers deep down to the bottom of the barrel. It comes in four colors pink, grey, while and blue. Before we start our reviews, let's get something straight. A Group Leader is a What to Expect community member who has been selected by our staff to help maintain a positive, supportive tone within a group. No one wants this to happen when you open a diaper pail, which is why Diaper Genie and Munchkin Step have both taken steps to eliminate the issue. It's much better than a standard trash can and way cheaper than pails that use special bags, but you'll have to live with a bit more stink. While both pails are popular options, Ive found that the Munchkin has a few advantages that make it my personal favorite. Others allow you to use standard trash bags. Weve all experienced the moment of opening the trash can and getting a sudden whiff of bad air. For every Step Diaper Pail sold, Munchkin will plant a tree.Measures 27" high x 12" deep; Comes with step . Throw a dirty diaper in a normal trash can, and you might find the smell sticks around for a while. The Munchkin Step uses a twist and seal method. Diaper Pail Refill For Diaper Genie Pails With Stronger Layers. This deodorizer works well, but it does need to be replaced roughly every 30 days. Just drop the diaper in, close the lid, and the diaper is released into the bag. Group Leaders communicate with staff moderators and escalate potential violations for review, but they dont moderate discussions. Besides, steel is much nicer to look at. think twice before sharing personal details, foster a friendly and supportive environment, remove fake accounts, spam and misinformation, delete posts that violate our community guidelines, reviewed by our medical review board and team of experts. Finding the right pail means finding the right one for you, which is a balance of multiple factors. Diaper Genie boasts Double Air-Tite clamps that work together with a carbon filter to deter odor build-up. Read More, It's not a bad design, but it doesn't contain smells as well as the Diaper Genie. You can email the site owner to let them know you were blocked. Refer to your owner's manual for definitive cleaning . Although they are more expensive, the Munchkin bag refills are nice, because they have baking soda for maximum odor control. Step on the foot pedal, allow the lid to lift up and insert the soiled diaper through the gap in the center of the pail. Are there alternatives? As Ive mentioned before, both Munchkin and Diaper Genie are quality products thatll get the intended job done. sold separately See the PAIL diaper pail in action. You also dont want it to be in the way. Are there more budget-friendly choices to consider? This system works very well, keeping smells away with minimal effort. Read More. Bags are annoying and it was still smelly. When youre preparing for your little one, your to buy list might be considerably longer. This design is actually very good at sealing in odor so it doesnt affect the roomthough when you empty the bag you're probably going to stink up the joint anyway. Playtex did add the option to buy sleeves with geometric prints that make the pail look prettier, but that does little to justify the other drawbacks here. We had the diaper genie for our first baby and the unit itself didn't last very long. Munchkin Step, owned by Arm & Hammer, can be used with either the Munchkin refill rings, or the Munchkin Snap, Seal, and Toss refill bags. There's minimal opportunity for bad smells to leak. Its not a substitute for professional medical advice or medical care. The Diaper Genie Complete has inside flaps (like a shelf) that close or open in time with the lid. Still, others have a simple hole that lets diapers fall to the bottom on their own. 2005-2023Everyday Health, Inc., a Ziff Davis company. I had a diaper genie many years ago for cleaning the cat box, and I remember it working well. A twist and seal opening keeps dirty diaper smells at bay. You're all set to get the latest from Reviewed. This is because its basically a big, stylish, steel trash can. Group Owners uphold the core values of the brand by reporting content that violates the community guidelines. The Diaper Genie has dimensions of 9.38 x 12.06 x 27 and weighs 8lbs when its empty. While both brands market their own liners, the Ubbi is compatible with any standard trash bag. Allison Banfield an experience mom of two, wife, writer, editor, and passionate parenting advocate! When you open it you do have to push the diaper in because as you close it retracts and closes as its way to help conceal odor(thats the only time you get whiff of the smell) but as soon as you close the lid smell is gone. Please select a reason for escalating this post to the WTE moderators: Connect with our community members by starting a discussion. Lets find out which one of these two is the best diaper pail for odor containment. However, Ive never had trouble cramming a diaper through the opening. The author of this article does not accept any responsibility for any liability, loss or risk, personal or otherwise, incurred as a consequence, directly or indirectly, from any information or advice contained here. The Dekor Plus operates with a very similar system to the Diaper Genie, with a refill consisting of one long trash bag you have to tie off and cut as the pail fills up. The Munchkin Step Pail is one of the very best Diaper Pails that one can get for around $60. Friends, diaper pails are not a necessity, but rather a luxury. He is from the self-styled "Cranberry Capitol of the World," which is, in fact, a real thing. They also hold just as many diapers (270), all for less cost. I agree. Diaper Genie II Elite, Diaper Genie Essentials and Diaper Genie II pails, Diaper Genie Expressions, and Diaper Genie Complete; Made with 7-layer film; Lavender-scented; error: We aim to show you accurate product information.